Ties are the problem. You can add a helper row, which would be obtrusive, to say the least, or try the following:
Change your formula in AT4 (currently =E4) to =E4+0.001*COLUMN(), then change AU4 (currently =I4) to =I4+0.001*COLUMN(), etc. for AT4 through BD4. This will keep your numbers looking the same in the workbook, but it will ever-so-slightly break any ties that occur and give you a proper ranking. Once that's done, enter the following formulas where indicated:
Fill down for each and you should be good to go...?
Bookmarks