#VALUE error in INDIRECT function

I have a table, starting at cell A2, like this:

List1	List2	List3
John	Gail	Steven
Betty	Mark	Mark
Bill	John	John

and a named range called Selected_Lists like this:

List1

List2

List3

The array formula {=IF(INDIRECT({"R2C1"},FALSE)=Selected_Lists,TRUE)} gives a #VALUE error.
If I highlight just the INDIRECT({"R2C1"},FALSE) portion and hit F9, it correctly evaluates to {"List1"}.

If I hardcode the cell R2C1 result into the formula like this:
=IF({"List1"}=Selected_Lists,TRUE)

It works just fine.

Why am I getting a data type mismatch with the INDIRECT function, and how can I correct it?

Thanks!

function INDEX will do it

Thanks everyone. That actually did point me in the right direction. I should have thought of INDEX.

Here is what I ended up with so far:
=IF(MATCH(INDEX(List_Table[#Headers],1,TRUNC((ROW()-ROW($M$27))/ROWS(List_Table))+1),Selected_Lists,0)>0,1,0)

This is just an intermediate step for a larger formula I am developing, but this part produces the desired results now. Thanks for the help.