Welcome to the Forum jeffamore!
First, it is generally better to attach your actual file instead of a picture. Few people are going to take the trouble to create a new file based on your picture. That way we can implement a solution and give you the file back. See yellow banner at the top of the page.
Here is an alternative for a formula you can put in C, with no other changes, although I haven't tested it. If you have trouble with it attach your file.
Also I discourage the use of merged cells. Consider "Center Across Selection" to get the look you want.
Bookmarks