INDEX function not working

I seriously need help here. Attached is a copy of my document and I have used the following formula:

=IFERROR(INDEX(Data!$F$2:$F$5839,MATCH(1,(Sheet3!A16=Data!A2:A5839)*(Sheet3!D1=Data!H2:H5839)*(Sheet3!L2=Data!K2:K5839),0)),"")

It is supposed to return "A*" but instead, there is no value. Due to the iferror() function, it has shown up as blank in cell L16 in Sheet3.

I have checked the format of the cells as well as tried different functions such as vlookup(), sumproduct(), etc. but nothing worked.

Can you help?

Thank you. That worked! Why do I need to press ctrl-shift-enter for this? As for the other formulas, we don't really need to do that.