Extracting data from column that fits criteria

Hello All,

Excel newbie here and have a question in regards to data extraction without using the built in autofilter from excel. I should also mention that I am using Excel 2007.

Given a column A of data, I want to make a new column B with the data from A that meet a certain criteria. It sounds pretty simple yet it makes me want to kick my computer since I cannot figure it out. Here is what I have written and I receive a #NUM! error:
A is the column of data, B is the extracted Data, A12 is the Count of how many met criteria. C2 is the Criteria Value.

HTML Code: 

Just numeric values. I was trying to be somewhat broad because the sheet I am making is rather extensive but I can attach if needed.

Sample.xlsx


The above is a sample of what I have been attempting to do. I have the raw data and criteria and want to produce the raw data that met criteria onto the filtered tab.

I was using the wrong cell for criteria.... -_-. You are right, once I fix that cell number it works perfectly. Wow I feel like an idiot.
Thank you so much XOR LX