Hello Chris,
The way to do this is create a 2 column table with the Material description in column 1 and the cost in column 2. Name this table say "tbl_MatCost". Also name the cells in the first column of the table say "Materials".
Now with the cell you want as a drop down select the Data option from the Menu and then click the Data Validation item in the Data Tools area then Data Validation.
In the 'Allow' box choose 'List' and enter 'Materials' in the Source box.
Name the drop down cell say "Selection"
Now in the cell that contains the price (C4 in my example) enter the formula
Bookmarks