Multipage problem with userforms

I've got a problem with a userform that's driving me nuts. I've googled and can't seem to find anyone with a similar problem.

I've got a fairly complicated userform that I've been using for a while and have since decided needs to have another page. When I add the multipage control, the second page is identical to the first. Any changes I make to the first page also happen to the second, and vice-versa. I've tried adding, deleting, and moving pages and the results are the same. What am I doing wrong? All the instructions I can find seem to make it simpler than what I'm doing.

Thanks,
Zach