Hi Shams,
I agree with Kaper to a large extent. I don't bother too much about titles. If the question makes sense and I have enough information, I'll have a go at at solution. I'm MORE inclined to try and produce a solution if there's a sample workbook. If a title is obviously bad, I'll usually warn the OP that the Moderator(s) might take exception and ask them to change it. In this case, there had already been a few posts, so I didn't bother.
Kaper is also right that the purpose of a good thread title is to make it more meaningful to other people searching the forum or just Googling an answer to their question. In this case, if someone were looking for COUNTIFS or Array Formula, they might come across this thread which probably wouldn't help them.
Though, that said, my solution used: and and so you never know.
So, Fotis is also correct in asking you to change your thread title. nathansav might have led you down the wrong path inadvertently by suggesting you needed an Array Formula. And, with over 200 posts, you should be expected to know better ... to be an experienced forum user, even if you are not an experienced Excel user
The thing is that I've used COUNTIFS and Array Formula and INDEX/MATCH in this reply, so there's a good chance that anyone searching for those topics might come across this thread anyway.
I think that Kaper's suggested thread title is a very good one ... but a little late in the day.
It's probably best not to keep challenging the Moderator(s) as that probably won't help your case and maybe earn more infractions or get you banned ... not good.
So, just draw a line and, next time, spend a little time trying to think of a thread title that summarises the problem you need to address. It doesn't mean you can't use COUNTIF, but maybe more in context. For example, "COUNTIF produces incorrect results" and the body of the thread explaining the background ... and a sample workbook. That title says you're using COUNTIF and you have a problem. Factual and it doesn't assume a solution.
Thanks again for the rep.
Kind regards, TMS
Bookmarks