MultiCriteria Indexing WITH Duplicates...HELP!

Hello Madman74 and Welcome to Excel Forum.
This reads like school work (must be accomplished by formulas). If so please read:
Nothing is more frustrating than to be working on homework and to get stuck. Without guidance, you might have no hope of finishing the assignment before the deadline. The Internet can be a big help in that respect, but without learning how to get the right answer, asking others to solve your homework questions for you simply becomes a downward spiral (and it's cheating).

We do not want to contribute to you cheating yourself out of your education, but we also acknowledge that seeking assistance to learn a concept is a legitimate request.

If you are genuinely interested in receiving help in the form of tutoring or coaching, then please rephrase the title of your original post to clearly indicate you are seeking coaching or tutoring help. Any forum members (who are willing to assist as a tutor) will modify their responses accordingly to facilitate your learning. Tutors don't tell you the answers, they help you figure it out for yourself; so don't expect answers, expect suggestions, or just plain hints. Also, be specific in describing the function/formula or technique you trying to learn, and tell us what you have attempted so far. Otherwise, expect your plea for homework answers to be ignored.

Since you are using the 2011 version you could accomplish the first task, acquiring the dates, using Index and Aggregate using Row as the K argument. Index and Aggregate should work to place the fruit with the proper date also using Countifs as the K argument.
If you would like for us to model these formulas using your data please upload the workbook from which the screen shot in post #1 is taken.
To upload a sample workbook click on the GO ADVANCED button below the Quick Reply window and then scroll down to Manage Attachments to open the upload window.
Let us know if you have any questions.