I'm trying to write a formula that would do the following between two sheets:

In Sheet 1 Reference the text in a cell - I'll call it B4

Look at at cells "Sheet2!$R$59:$FZ$69" (yes, I need an absolute reference because I intend to drag the formula) to see if a match to "Sheet1!B4" is in that range

Then, report the data that is found in the cell next it. (so if a match to "Sheet1!B4" is found in "Sheet2!R61" then report "Sheet2!R63 in the cell).

It strikes me as pretty easy, but I cannot get it to work. I'm trying to make quick work of an enormous sheet, but I cannot figure out what type of dynamic formula to write. Please help!