Vlookup, Index or Match?

I have a spreadsheet that I am trying to get and exact match on a summary page. The criterias are
if the data in B3 & C3 matches the data on a separate tab but same cell references then the data from cells F3:BR3 should be exact for all for all cells that have the exact same criteria as B3 & C3. To explain myself further. If a cell b3 have a # of 00057 and cell C3 have a nuber of 058 then all cells in those two columns that match those criteria should have the same percentage from column F5:BR2631.

This is an index formula I am trying and I am getting #VALUE! ERROR. Would VLOOKUP be better and can someone assist me with the formula.

Also cross posted here
http://www.mrexcel.com/forum/excel-q...dex-match.html

Thanks