Luke,
After looking at your posted workbook, Pete has it right on the money, you have many entries in columns B, C, and D that are text instead of using Excel datecodes. To correct this, in cell K2 put this formula:
Copy over to L2 and then copy down until you have no more rows with data. Copy the block of decimal numbers, select cell C2, right-click, paste-special -> values. Then format the cells as custom to hh:mm:ss AM/PM
Afterwards you can delete what is in columns K:L
Then apply the conditional formatting again.
Bookmarks