Checkbook Register

I like using the checkbook register template in MS Excel, but I want two
debit columns and two credit columns against the one balance column. I
figured out how to copy the column, but it does not calculate in the balance
column. How do you do that?

You would need to change the formula in the balance column to incorporate your
two new columns.

Presumably, the current formula is something like:

=f2+d3-e3

And you would need something like:

=h2+d3+e3-f3-g3

--
Regards,
Fred


"PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>I like using the checkbook register template in MS Excel, but I want two
> debit columns and two credit columns against the one balance column. I
> figured out how to copy the column, but it does not calculate in the balance
> column. How do you do that?

Thanks for responding, but that's not quite what I was looking for. The
formula in the balance column is like this:
"=IF(AND(ISBLANK(F9),ISBLANK(G9)),"",H8-F9+G9)" for a line that has a debit
entry. Simply copying it and adding the added column does not work because
now, for example, f and g are debit columns, h and i are credit columns, and
j is now my balance column. I get all kinds of errors about logic, just
clicking the columns won't enter them. So really, if you understand this
formula, maybe you can just tell me how to make f and g debit h and i credit
= to J, and no I am not trying to enter two debits or credits on one line,
each line will have only one action from one of those four columns. So, what
do you think. I hope this is clear.

"Fred Smith" wrote:

> You would need to change the formula in the balance column to incorporate your
> two new columns.
>
> Presumably, the current formula is something like:
>
> =f2+d3-e3
>
> And you would need something like:
>
> =h2+d3+e3-f3-g3
>
> --
> Regards,
> Fred
>
>
> "PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
> >I like using the checkbook register template in MS Excel, but I want two
> > debit columns and two credit columns against the one balance column. I
> > figured out how to copy the column, but it does not calculate in the balance
> > column. How do you do that?
>
>
>

If you added additional debit and credit columns, your formula would change to:

=if(and(f9="",g9="",h9="",i9=""),"",h8-f9-g9+h9+i9)

It's the same formula as I originally gave you, except you are using columns F
to I, whereas I had used D to H.

The f9="" is a shorter way of writing isblank(f9). It's checking to see if all
four columns are blank. If so, nothing is displayed in the balance column.

--
Regards,
Fred


"PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Thanks for responding, but that's not quite what I was looking for. The
> formula in the balance column is like this:
> "=IF(AND(ISBLANK(F9),ISBLANK(G9)),"",H8-F9+G9)" for a line that has a debit
> entry. Simply copying it and adding the added column does not work because
> now, for example, f and g are debit columns, h and i are credit columns, and
> j is now my balance column. I get all kinds of errors about logic, just
> clicking the columns won't enter them. So really, if you understand this
> formula, maybe you can just tell me how to make f and g debit h and i credit
> = to J, and no I am not trying to enter two debits or credits on one line,
> each line will have only one action from one of those four columns. So, what
> do you think. I hope this is clear.
>
> "Fred Smith" wrote:
>
>> You would need to change the formula in the balance column to incorporate
>> your
>> two new columns.
>>
>> Presumably, the current formula is something like:
>>
>> =f2+d3-e3
>>
>> And you would need something like:
>>
>> =h2+d3+e3-f3-g3
>>
>> --
>> Regards,
>> Fred
>>
>>
>> "PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>> news:[email protected]...
>> >I like using the checkbook register template in MS Excel, but I want two
>> > debit columns and two credit columns against the one balance column. I
>> > figured out how to copy the column, but it does not calculate in the
>> > balance
>> > column. How do you do that?
>>
>>
>>

Thanks for this info, this helps some more, entering that 'isblank' is a
trip. I will try the way you have it here. What is wrong with my formula
(below) I did manage to enter. this is a credit entry in I10; J10 is the
balance column where nothing happens when I tab past it.
=IF(AND(ISBLANK(F10),ISBLANK(G10),ISBLANK(H10)),"",J9-F10-G10+H10+I10
I really appreciate your help
Barbara
"Fred Smith" wrote:

> If you added additional debit and credit columns, your formula would change to:
>
> =if(and(f9="",g9="",h9="",i9=""),"",h8-f9-g9+h9+i9)
>
> It's the same formula as I originally gave you, except you are using columns F
> to I, whereas I had used D to H.
>
> The f9="" is a shorter way of writing isblank(f9). It's checking to see if all
> four columns are blank. If so, nothing is displayed in the balance column.
>
> --
> Regards,
> Fred
>
>
> "PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> news:[email protected]...
> > Thanks for responding, but that's not quite what I was looking for. The
> > formula in the balance column is like this:
> > "=IF(AND(ISBLANK(F9),ISBLANK(G9)),"",H8-F9+G9)" for a line that has a debit
> > entry. Simply copying it and adding the added column does not work because
> > now, for example, f and g are debit columns, h and i are credit columns, and
> > j is now my balance column. I get all kinds of errors about logic, just
> > clicking the columns won't enter them. So really, if you understand this
> > formula, maybe you can just tell me how to make f and g debit h and i credit
> > = to J, and no I am not trying to enter two debits or credits on one line,
> > each line will have only one action from one of those four columns. So, what
> > do you think. I hope this is clear.
> >
> > "Fred Smith" wrote:
> >
> >> You would need to change the formula in the balance column to incorporate
> >> your
> >> two new columns.
> >>
> >> Presumably, the current formula is something like:
> >>
> >> =f2+d3-e3
> >>
> >> And you would need something like:
> >>
> >> =h2+d3+e3-f3-g3
> >>
> >> --
> >> Regards,
> >> Fred
> >>
> >>
> >> "PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
> >> news:[email protected]...
> >> >I like using the checkbook register template in MS Excel, but I want two
> >> > debit columns and two credit columns against the one balance column. I
> >> > figured out how to copy the column, but it does not calculate in the
> >> > balance
> >> > column. How do you do that?
> >>
> >>
> >>
>
>
>

Your formula should work, assuming you end it with two parentheses.

Tabbing past a cell should have no effect. The cell should calculate as soon as
you enter something in one of the debit or credit columns. Is your formula in
cell J10?

When you say 'I10 is a credit entry', do you want the number added to or
subtracted from the balance? With your formula, you are adding it to the
balance.

--
Regards,
Fred


"PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
> Thanks for this info, this helps some more, entering that 'isblank' is a
> trip. I will try the way you have it here. What is wrong with my formula
> (below) I did manage to enter. this is a credit entry in I10; J10 is the
> balance column where nothing happens when I tab past it.
> =IF(AND(ISBLANK(F10),ISBLANK(G10),ISBLANK(H10)),"",J9-F10-G10+H10+I10
> I really appreciate your help
> Barbara
> "Fred Smith" wrote:
>
>> If you added additional debit and credit columns, your formula would change
>> to:
>>
>> =if(and(f9="",g9="",h9="",i9=""),"",h8-f9-g9+h9+i9)
>>
>> It's the same formula as I originally gave you, except you are using columns
>> F
>> to I, whereas I had used D to H.
>>
>> The f9="" is a shorter way of writing isblank(f9). It's checking to see if
>> all
>> four columns are blank. If so, nothing is displayed in the balance column.
>>
>> --
>> Regards,
>> Fred
>>
>>
>> "PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>> news:[email protected]...
>> > Thanks for responding, but that's not quite what I was looking for. The
>> > formula in the balance column is like this:
>> > "=IF(AND(ISBLANK(F9),ISBLANK(G9)),"",H8-F9+G9)" for a line that has a
>> > debit
>> > entry. Simply copying it and adding the added column does not work because
>> > now, for example, f and g are debit columns, h and i are credit columns,
>> > and
>> > j is now my balance column. I get all kinds of errors about logic, just
>> > clicking the columns won't enter them. So really, if you understand this
>> > formula, maybe you can just tell me how to make f and g debit h and i
>> > credit
>> > = to J, and no I am not trying to enter two debits or credits on one line,
>> > each line will have only one action from one of those four columns. So,
>> > what
>> > do you think. I hope this is clear.
>> >
>> > "Fred Smith" wrote:
>> >
>> >> You would need to change the formula in the balance column to incorporate
>> >> your
>> >> two new columns.
>> >>
>> >> Presumably, the current formula is something like:
>> >>
>> >> =f2+d3-e3
>> >>
>> >> And you would need something like:
>> >>
>> >> =h2+d3+e3-f3-g3
>> >>
>> >> --
>> >> Regards,
>> >> Fred
>> >>
>> >>
>> >> "PurpleBabs" <[email protected]> wrote in message
>> >> news:[email protected]...
>> >> >I like using the checkbook register template in MS Excel, but I want two
>> >> > debit columns and two credit columns against the one balance column. I
>> >> > figured out how to copy the column, but it does not calculate in the
>> >> > balance
>> >> > column. How do you do that?
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>>
>>
>>