Conditional Formatting stops working after adding column

I have a conditional formula that highlights dates red when it meets a certain criteria. The file named MS Working, the conditional formatting formula (formula below) works as it should with no issues. The other file MS NOT Working, the conditional formatting formula (formula below) has stopped working as it should. What I did? I inserted a new column to the left. Where the MS Working file has only 1 column to the far left, the MS NOT Working file now has 2 columns to the far left.

It seems as if the formula adjusted itself when I inserted the new column; however, its not working. I've tried everything to the best of my knowledge to figure this out. What can I do to fix it?

MS Working
Conditional Formula: =AND(TODAY()>B3,NOT(ISODD(COLUMN())),B3<>"",OR(C3="",C3=0),B3<>0)

MS NOT Working
Conditional Formula: =AND(TODAY()>C3,NOT(ISODD(COLUMN())),C3<>"",OR(D3="",D3=0),C3<>0)

Previously you tested for EVEN columns; however, adding a column moved verything to ODD:
=AND(TODAY()>B3,ISODD(COLUMN()),B3<>"",OR(C3="",C3=0),B3<>0)