Use INDEX function to look for nth match

Currently I am building an automated planning sheet which makes use of multiple worksheets. There is an overall sheet which pulls data from the project list based on the INDEX-MATCH formula.

The problem now is, as I put two equal values (names) in the project lists beneath each other, it always pulls out the first match and does not look beyond that first match if first match is not correct for another correct match below the first given match. The match is based on the name and if it is in between the start- and end date of the given project.

In the given Excel the problem is visualized. In sheet 'Projectenlijst', there's given two project for the first worker except within the sheet 'Overzichtsplanning' it only shows the first given match and not the second match.

Is there any possible way for the INDEX-MATCH formula to continue searching until first found match is true?